Accreditation · Guide

Three ISO 15189 Findings Your LIMS Should Make Impossible

Unchecked reagent lots, results released on an overdue analyser, and critical results nobody phoned. Each one is usually a records problem, and each one can be turned into a rule the system enforces. Roughly a 6-minute read.

Most ISO 15189 findings aren't about bad science. The lab ran the comparison, kept the calibration schedule, made the phone call. The finding comes because the record doesn't show it, or shows it happened in the wrong order, or lives somewhere the result path never looks.

That's the gap a laboratory information system should close. Not by storing more documents, but by refusing to let the next step happen until the evidence for the last one exists. Here are three findings where that difference matters most, what the standard expects, and how we built FreshLIMS to handle each one.

1. A reagent lot that went into use without being accepted

What the standard expects. ISO 15189:2022 clause 6.6 covers reagents and consumables: they should be checked before use, and the lab should be able to show it. For most quantitative assays that means a lot-to-lot comparison, running the same samples on the current and new lot and checking the difference against a limit you've set.

How it goes wrong. The comparison is run, eyeballed and filed. Six months later an assessor picks a patient result and asks which lot ran it, whether that lot was accepted first, on what data, against what limit, and who signed it off. The answer is in a binder, a spreadsheet, or someone's memory.

How FreshLIMS handles it.

  • A new lot is received into quarantine, recording product, catalogue and lot number, expiry, analyser, assays, storage and condition.
  • Lot-to-lot rows compare current against new, per sample and assay, with the percentage difference worked out live against the allowed limit.
  • If any row is outside its limit, the lot can't be accepted. Accepting without a comparison (QC-only, certificate, or not required) needs written evidence. Rejecting a lot needs a reason. An expired lot can't be accepted at all.
  • A calibration that used a calibrator lot which wasn't accepted, or had expired that day, is flagged.
  • Lots are never deleted. Opening (with its in-use expiry) and finishing are recorded, and every step is on the audit trail.

2. Patient results released on an analyser that was overdue

What the standard expects. Clauses 6.4 and 6.5 cover equipment, its calibration and its maintenance. Keeping a schedule is the start. The lab also has to act when equipment is out of service or overdue, and not keep reporting from it.

How it goes wrong. A calibration lapses on Tuesday and nobody notices until Thursday. In between, the analyser runs patient samples, and those results are approved and reported like any others. The calibration record says it was overdue, but nothing in the release process ever read it.

How FreshLIMS handles it.

  • Calibration, maintenance and EQA records are kept against each analyser in the same system as the results.
  • When patient results are approved, at the run or on the report, FreshLIMS checks that analyser's records at that moment.
  • If the analyser is out of service, overdue for maintenance, or overdue for calibration of that assay, the patient results can't be released.
  • The message names the analyser, the reason and the assays held, and says how to clear it: put the analyser back in service, record the overdue calibration or maintenance, or re-run the samples on another analyser. The hold lifts as soon as that's done.
  • An out-of-service analyser is stopped earlier still. You can't add patient samples to its run or key in patient results for it. QC and calibrators can still run, because that's how you bring it back.

3. A critical result that was reported before anyone phoned it

What the standard expects. ISO 15189 clause 7.4.1.3 and the Royal College of Pathologists' guidance (G158) expect critical results to be communicated promptly to someone who can act on them, and the communication to be recorded: who was told, by whom, and when, with the result read back.

How it goes wrong. The result is approved at the run and the report goes out, while the call is "about to happen". Or the call is made and written on a notepad that never reaches the record. Either way, the order of events can't be shown afterwards.

How FreshLIMS handles it.

  • A critical patient value can't be approved at the run until the call is logged, so it can't be authorised first and phoned later.
  • A report can't be approved while any critical result on it hasn't been phoned.
  • A positive blood culture can't be finalised, or its report released, until the call is recorded.
  • Every critical result and positive blood culture sits on one Critical Results worklist, showing who phoned whom and when. It stays open until the clinician's read-back is confirmed, so "phoned but not read back" is visible, not assumed.

What a system can't do for you

It's worth being exact about where the edges are, because an assessor will be.

  • The rules only work on records that exist. An analyser with no calibration or maintenance records isn't held, because there's nothing to be overdue against. Setting up the schedule is still the lab's job.
  • Release needs the call logged, not the read-back. A logged call lets the report go out. The entry stays open on the worklist until read-back is confirmed, and closing that loop is a person's job.
  • An unaccepted lot isn't blocked from runs. Using one on a run raises a warning rather than a hard stop, because there are legitimate reasons to run one, such as the comparison itself. Acceptance is what's enforced.
  • The software isn't the accreditation. UKAS accredits the laboratory against its own scope and practice. A LIMS provides the evidence and enforces the order of events. It doesn't hold the accreditation for you.

For the wider picture of what an assessor checks, see our ISO 15189 readiness guide and the section-by-section ISO 15189:2022 checklist.

The takeaway

Each of these findings has the same shape. The lab had a rule, the rule lived in a document, and the result path never checked it. The fix isn't more paperwork. It's making the next step depend on the evidence for the last one, so the record exists because the work was done in the right order, not because someone rebuilt it the week before the assessment.

Turn your quality rules into the way the lab works.

Reagent lot acceptance, equipment holds and critical-result calls, alongside live Westgard QC and an append-only audit trail. Plans from £1,250/month, tailored to your lab.

Request a quote See the Lab Platform